Ichabod married Esther Barnes in 1703 in Plympton, Plymouth, Massachusetts, United States. Esther was born on 18 Feb 1682 in Plymouth, Plymouth Colony, British Colonial America; died in 1703 in Massachusetts Bay Colony, British Colonial America. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

Ichabod married Patience Holmes on 27 Nov 1712 in Plymouth, Plymouth, Massachusetts Bay, British Colonial America. Patience was born on 3 Nov 1690 in Plymouth, Plymouth Colony, British Colonial America; died on 8 Sep 1755 in Middleborough, Plymouth, Massachusetts Bay Colony, British Colonial America; was buried in 1755 in The Green, Middleborough, Plymouth, Massachusetts Bay Colony, British Colonial America. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]