Carlisle Benjamin Tooker, † < >

1800 - 1833  (32 years)

• Name	Carlisle Benjamin Tooker  [1, 2, 3, 4]
  Suffix	† < >
  Birth	5 Sep 1800	South Haven, Brookhaven, Suffolk, NY   [2]
  Baptism	5 Sep 1819	South Haven (Presbyterian Church), Brookhaven, Suffolk, NY   [1, 5]
  Gender	Male
  Death	14 Jan 1833	Center Moriches, Brookhaven, Suffolk, NY   [2]
  Burial	Center Moriches, Suffolk, New York, United States
  Person ID	I5787	My Genealogy
  Last Modified	6 Nov 2023

  
  

  Father	Zophar Tooker, ^,   b. 13 Feb 1767, Brookhaven, Suffolk, New York, USA d. Dec 1857, South Haven, Suffolk, New York, USA (Age 90 years)
  Mother	Mehitable Hetty Conklin,   b. 1778, South Haven, Suffolk, New York, United States d. 17 Aug 1865, Brooklyn, Kings County (Brooklyn), New York, United States of America (Age 87 years)
  Marriage	1799	South Haven, Suffolk, New York, United States
  Family ID	F28	Group Sheet  |  Family Chart

  
  

  Family	Mary Ann Brown, ^,   b. 5 Feb 1807, Fire Place (now Brookhaven Hamlet), Brookhaven, Suffolk, NY d. 8 Jan 1896, Center Moriches, Suffolk, New York, United States (Age 88 years)
  Marriage	26 Sep 1826  [2, 6]
  Children	1. Benjamin Brown Tooker, (i) ^,   b. 11 Mar 1827, South Haven, Suffolk, New York, United States d. 27 May 1883, East Islip, Islip, Suffolk, NY (Age 56 years)   2. Mary Tooker, <,   b. 13 Jul 1828, Center Moriches, Brookhaven, Suffolk, NY d. New York, United States   3. Edwin Tooker, <,   b. 15 Oct 1829, Center Moriches, Brookhaven, Suffolk, NY d. 14 Jan 1833, Center Moriches, Brookhaven, Suffolk, NY (Age 3 years)   4. Zophar Carlisle Tooker, ^,   b. 14 Sep 1831, Fire Place (now Brookhaven Hamlet), Brookhaven, Suffolk, NY d. 23 Jun 1889, Brookhaven, Suffolk, NY (Age 57 years)   5. Zopher Tooker,   b. 14 Sep 1831, Bellport, Suffolk, New York, United States d. 23 Aug 1889, Brookhaven, Suffolk, New York, United States (Age 57 years)
  Family ID	F428	Group Sheet  |  Family Chart
  Last Modified	27 May 2025

  
  

• Notes

  [That the Carlisle of the South Haven Presbyterian Church records, and the Benjamin of Ralph Clymer Hawkins are the same person seems likely, and is the conclusion of the Long Island Genealogy source. Our conclusion is based on the names given children, and the time period—when there were not all that many families living in the South Haven/Fire Place communities. However, it must be admitted that the conclusion is somewhat speculative, based on the evidence so far examined. Detailed census records for this period are not available.] -- MERGED NOTE ------------ This likely was not an infant baptism. The four Zopher and Sophia Tooker children, Fanny, Carlisle, Charlotte and John Lovet, were baptized the same day.

  
  

• Sources

  [S39] South Haven Presbyterian Church, Session Minutes and Records (1800 - 1903), p. 5. [S13] Long Island Genealogy Surname Database, online [http://longislandgenealogy.com ], http://www.longislandsurnames.com/genealogy/getperson.php?personID=I01233&tree=Brown. [S2] Ralph Clymer Hawkins, 1897- ., A Hawkins genealogy, 1635-1939 : record of the descendants of Robert Hawkins of Charlestown, Massachusetts (Baltimore : Published for the Hawkins Association by Gateway Press, 1987), p. 146. Referring to Elilu Hawkins, Mary Ann Brown's second husband: "He married (2) Sep. 26, 1837, Mary Ann (Brown), widow of Benjamin Tooker. She was born Feb. 5, 1807, and died Jan. 8, 1896." [S332] Compiled by Gary Robert & Lynn (DiClemente) Brown, "Brown Family of England and Brookhaven,"; , Personal Collection (copy), . Benjamin Brown, b. in Middle Island, Sept 25, 1784; drowned with ten other men off Old Inlet opposite Bellport, Nov. 5, 1813. This inlet through the Great South Beach, was then known as "New Inlet" and "Smiths Inlet" and has been closed for over a hundred years. His body was recovered and buried in Fire Place and later moved to the Bellport Cemetery. [He] m. Mary Ann Leek or Leeke. She was b. Aug 20, 1789; d. Apr. 2, 1843. She was probably a Middle Island woman. Children as given in the family Bible formerly owned by the late T. Leverett Brown: 1. Mary Ann, b. Feb 5, 1807; d. Jan 8, 1896. M. Benjamin Tooker, probably of Moriches, L.I., N.Y. by whom she had four children. He died and she m. 2nd, Elihu Hawkins by whom she had a son. 2. Alfred Benjamin, b. Sept 7, 1808. See below. 3. Samuel, b. Oct 2, 1810. He moved away, probably to New Yor or Brooklyn where he died. M. Susan L. Robinson. No record of any children. 4. Dorothy (Dolly), b. Dec 6, 1812; d. of consumption, May 25, 1834. * This account is ambiguous. Note that just previous it was indicated that Hannah Kinge was his wife, daughter of William and Dorothy Kinge. Perhaps these are typographical errors. No source has been found that indicates that he had a second wife, Dorothy. ** The John Tutthill to whom Richard entrusted his family and estate was not the John Tutthill described here, but rather a neighbor and friend, John Tutthill [i]; this John's wife Deliverance Kinge was a sibling to Hannah Kinge, Richard's wife. A John Tutthill does marry into the family, marrying Richard's granddaughter Elizabeth by his son Jonathan. This John Tutthill [iii] was John Tutthill's [i] grandson. See source reference: New York Genealogy and Biographical Record "The Family of Lieutenant Richard Browne," Vol. 31, p. 66 [S39] South Haven Presbyterian Church, Session Minutes and Records (1800 - 1903), p. 5. Church record did not contain middle name. [S332] Compiled by Gary Robert & Lynn (DiClemente) Brown, "Brown Family of England and Brookhaven,"; , Personal Collection (copy), . 6. Benjamin Brown, b. in Middle Island, Sept 25, 1784; drowned with ten other men off Old Inlet opposite Bellport, Nov. 5, 1813.... Children: 1. Mary Ann, b. Feb 5, 1807; d. Jan 8, 1896. M. Benjamin Tooker, probably of Moriches, L.I., N.Y. by whom she had four children. He died and she m. 2nd, Elihu Hawkins by whom she had a son.