Children |
| 1. Sylvester Prince Tuthill, b. Oct 1840, Southold, Suffolk, New York, United States d. 8 Apr 1912, Greenport, Southold, Suffolk, New York, United States (Age 71 years) |
| 2. Francis Tuthill, b. 1841, Southold, Suffolk, New York, United States d. Yes, date unknown |
| 3. Harriet Melissa Tuthill, b. 2 Apr 1837, Cutchogue, Southold, Suffolk, New York, United States d. 30 Oct 1887, Southold, Suffolk, New York, United States (Age 50 years) |
| 4. Lewis Hallock Tuthill, b. 22 Apr 1835, Mattituck, Southold, Suffolk, New York, United States d. 10 Nov 1902, Southold, Suffolk, New York, United States (Age 67 years) |
|