Children |
| 1. Elizabeth Tuthill, b. 1751, , Suffolk, New York, USA d. 1 Jan 1808 (Age 57 years) |
| 2. James Tuthill, Jr., b. 5 May 1753, Suffolk Co., NY d. 26 May 1826, Speonk, Southampton, Suffolk, NY (Age 73 years) |
| 3. Abagail Tuthill, b. 18 Feb 1758, Suffolk Co., NY d. Yes, date unknown |
| 4. Nancy Tuthill, b. Abt 1759/60 d. Yes, date unknown |
| 5. Hannah Tuthill, b. 5 Sep 1761, Wading River, Brookhaven, Suffolk, NY d. 21 Mar 1834, Swezeytown, Middle Island, Brookhaven, Suffolk, NY (Age 72 years) |
| 6. David Tuthill, >, b. 18 Jun 1762, Wading River, Brookhaven, Suffolk, NY d. 29 Oct 1849 (Age 87 years) |
| 7. John Tuthill, b. 1764 d. Yes, date unknown |
| 8. Mehitabel Tuthill, >, b. 10 Aug 1767, Southold, Suffolk, New York Colony, British Colonial America d. 1859, Middle Island, Brookhaven, Suffolk, NY (Age 91 years) |
| 9. Lydia Tuthill, b. 2 Jan 1770, Wading River, Brookhaven, Suffolk, NY d. 25 Jul 1833, Cutchogue, Suffolk, New York, United States (Age 63 years) |
| 10. Joshua Tuthill, b. 17 Sep 1773, Suffolk Co., NY d. 21 Sep 1860, Suffolk Co., NY (Age 87 years) |
| 11. Harmony Tuthill, b. Aug 1776 d. Yes, date unknown |
|