| Children |
| | 1. Ella Cahill Tuthill, b. 11 Jul 1851 d. 17 Dec 1860 (Age 9 years) |
| | 2. Harrison Howell Tuthill, b. 11 Apr 1853 d. Yes, date unknown |
| | 3. Elizabeth Hull Tuthill, b. 13 Mar 1855 d. Yes, date unknown |
| | 4. Ira Brewster Tuthill, b. 13 Mar 1855 d. 3 Aug 1855 (Age 0 years) |
| | 5. Hannah Rosetta Tuthill, b. 18 Nov 1857 d. Yes, date unknown |
| | 6. Jeremiah Goldsmith Tuthill, b. 19 Jul 1861 d. Yes, date unknown |
| | 7. Howard Grant Tuthill, b. 14 Sep 1863 d. Yes, date unknown |
| | 8. John Terry Tuthill, Sr. >, b. 19 Sep 1867, Patchogue, Brookhaven, Suffolk, New York, United States d. 7 Oct 1944, Port Jefferson, Brookhaven, Suffolk, New York, United States (Age 77 years) |
|