| Children |
| | 1. Charles Wilson Tuthill, b. 14 Mar 1846, Speonk, Suffolk, New York, United States d. 13 Apr 1892, Bayport, Suffolk, New York, United States (Age 46 years) |
| | 2. George Buel Tuthill, b. 2 Jul 1841, Speonk, Suffolk, New York, United States d. 19 Jul 1912, Patchogue, Suffolk, New York, United States (Age 71 years) |
| | 3. Henry E. Tuthill, b. 29 Apr 1844, Speonk, Sfflk, N-Yr d. 30 Jan 1902 (Age 57 years) |
| | 4. Phebe Louise Tuthill, b. 21 Dec 1849, Speonk, Sfflk, N-Yr d. 1854 (Age 4 years) |
| | 5. Catharine Tuthill, b. 13 Oct 1836, Shelter Island,Suffolk,New York d. 7 Aug 1874, Bayport, Long Island, New York (Age 37 years) |
|