1806 - 1867 (61 years)
| Elizabeth Horton | |
| B: | 20 Dec 1868 |
| Southold, Suffolk, New York, United States | |
| D: | 5 Nov 1959 |
| East Hampton, Suffolk, New York, United States | |
| Anna "Annie" Wells Tuthill | |
| B: | 23 Jun 1843 |
| Riverhead, Suffolk, NY | |
| D: | 9 Feb 1937 |
| Amagansett, Long Island, New York | |
| Horace Bartlet Horton | |
| B: | 11 Dec 1837 |
| Cutchogue, Southold, Suffolk, New York, United States | |
| M: | 31 Jan 1867 |
| Cutchogue,Suffolk,New York | |
| D: | 8 Nov 1870 |
| Amagansett, Long Island, New York | |
| Annie Smith | |
| B: | 8 Feb 1870 |
| Patchogue, Brookhaven, Suffolk, New York, United States | |
| D: | 22 Feb 1870 |
| Patchogue, Brookhaven, Suffolk, New York, United States | |
| Jane Cecelia Tuthill | |
| B: | 16 Dec 1847 |
| Riverhead, Suffolk, New York, United States | |
| D: | 8 Feb 1870 |
| Patchogue, Brookhaven, Suffolk, New York, United States | |
| Martenus Smith | |
| B: | May 1846 |
| Patchogue, Brookhaven, Suffolk, New York, United States | |
| M: | 26 Nov 1868 |
| D: | 31 Aug 1918 |
| Patchogue, Brookhaven, Suffolk, New York, United States | |
|
| Joanna Hallock | |
| B: | 1806 |
| Southampton, Suffolk, New York, United States | |
| D: | 19 Nov 1867 |
| Riverhead, Suffolk, New York, United States | |
| Jehiel Tuthill | |
| B: | 1802 |
| Shelter Island, Suffolk, New York, United States | |
| M: | 14 Oct 1826 |
| Shelter Island,Suffolk,New York | |
| D: | 1 Aug 1866 |
| Riverhead, Suffolk, New York, United States | |
