1751 - 1819 (67 years)
| Phebe Ann Prince | |
| B: | 16 Oct 1821 |
| Southold, Suffolk, New York | |
| D: | 12 Aug 1913 |
| Jacob Hallock Tuthill | |
| B: | 31 Aug 1814 |
| Mattituck, Suffolk, N.Y. | |
| M: | 23 Dec 1856 |
| Southold, Suffolk, New York | |
| D: | 16 Sep 1907 |
| Mattituck, Suff., N. Y. | |
| Benjamin W. Case | |
| B: | 20 Feb 1847 |
| Southold, Suffolk County, New York, United States | |
| D: | 3 Dec 1920 |
| Southold, Suffolk, New York, United States | |
| Benjamin Wells Case | |
| B: | 8 Dec 1822 |
| M: | 1842 |
| Suffolk,Ny | |
| D: | 10 Aug 1846 |
| Phebe Horton | |
| B: | 12 Dec 1784 |
| Southold, Suffolk, New York, United States | |
| D: | 1844 |
| Southold, Suffolk, New York, USA | |
| Ezra Prince | |
| B: | 1 Mar 1779 |
| Southold, Long Island, New York | |
| M: | 10 Feb 1804 |
| Southold,Suffolk,New York | |
| D: | 18 May 1826 |
| Southold, Long Island, New York | |
| Mary Horton | |
| B: | 5 Jun 1789 |
| Cutchogue, Southold, Suffolk, New York, United States | |
| D: | 31 Jan 1857 |
| Southold, Suffolk, New York, United States | |
| Jesse Tuthill | |
| B: | 1775 |
| Mattituck, Suffolk, New York Colony, British Colonial America | |
| M: | 1 Jun 1821 |
| Cutchogue, Southold, Suffolk, New York, United States | |
| D: | 8 Aug 1844 |
| Mattituck, Southold, Suffolk, New York, United States | |
|
| Abigail Horton | |
| B: | 3 Nov 1751 |
| Southold, Suffolk, New York Colony, British Colonial America | |
| D: | 31 Mar 1819 |
| Southold, Suffolk, New York, United States | |
| Jonathan Horton | |
| B: | 1739 |
| Southold, Suffolk, New York, United States | |
| M: | 26 Apr 1772 |
| Southold, Suffolk, New York Colony, British Colonial America | |
| D: | 5 Oct 1808 |
| Southold, Suffolk, New York, United States | |
